We do not yet know whether these technologies will ever be used in the future. The high degree of uncertainty over their effectiveness and especially over the negative collateral impacts fuel the mistrust of a large part of the scientific community.
by
Giuseppe Sammarco
27 May 2021
6 min read
by
Giuseppe Sammarco
27 May 2021
6 min read
In order to restore the earth's energy balance and counteract global warming, it is theoretically possible to act not only on the root cause (reducing human emissions to zero) but also on the other factors that determine this balance. This type of intervention is called “climate engineering” and is divided into two main categories: the removal of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere (the CDR), and the futuristic and somewhat controversial Solar Radiation Management (SRM) that we will look at in this article. SRM techniques are very different from CDR both in terms of maturity (they are still in the research phase and for now the actions under discussion are purely hypothetical) and in terms of costs and risk profiles. In fact, the unwanted impacts of SRM are little known or completely unknown and it is precisely these uncertainties that mean its possible use in the future is still the subject of much debate. To understand the reason for so many doubts, it is enough to describe what SRM involves. Put simply, SRM aims to counteract global warming with interventions that increase the amount of solar radiation reflected from the surface and the atmosphere, preventing its absorption and transformation into heat by the earth system.
SRM can be grouped into six categories with fascinating names reminiscent of the science fiction vision of a Jules Verne novel. The first is known as “stratospheric aerosol injection” and is inspired by what happens during volcanic eruptions: clouds of ash come out of the volcano and rise into the atmosphere (the famous plume) releasing large quantities of sulfur dioxide which, when combined with water vapor, form sulfuric acid aerosols capable of reflecting sunlight. In order to achieve a similar effect, some climate scientists have proposed using planes or balloons at high altitudes to introduce artificially special aerosols into the atmosphere. However, it is very difficult today to assess what the overall impact of their use would be (which aerosols will be used? Perhaps sulfur dioxide with the risk of creating acid rain?) and consequently, the degree of uncertainty over the final effect remains high. The second technique is called “marine cloud brightening.” This technology would involve the use of special systems installed on ships to spray seawater (salt spray) toward the clouds above the sea. The salt spray would facilitate the condensation of the vapor held in the clouds into water droplets, causing the clouds to enlarge and making them brighter, meaning that they would better reflect the sunlight. In this case, too, there is a lot of concern this technique may influence other mechanisms of the climate system, generating negative impacts.
Another proposal under discussion is “high albedo crops and buildings”. In simple terms, it is a question of making the roofs and facades of buildings more reflective, by painting them white, for example, as was done in the past in many of the sunniest coastal villages (nothing new under the sun, you might say). The same strategy could be applied to crops, introducing genetic modifications to give the leaves of plants a particular shine capable of reflecting the sun's rays. To achieve the same result on large ocean surfaces, scientists have come up with an intervention known as “ocean mirrors”: ships equipped with special systems would sail around, creating millions of tiny micro bubbles on the surface of the ocean, using special chemical additives to make them last for longer. This would create large white trails (like those formed when a ship passes by) capable of reflecting ten-times more sunlight than normal. One of the potentially negative aspects is that less sunlight would penetrate deep into the water, reducing photosynthesis and the growth rate of marine vegetation, with negative impacts transmitted along the entire food chain. Furthermore, creating so many micro bubbles on the surface of the ocean and above all keeping them “alive” for several days or weeks would require large amounts of energy.
The next technique sounds like a sort of facelift surgery: "Cirrus cloud thinning". Cirrus clouds are high-altitude white clouds made up of dust-like ice crystals. Whilst it is true that cirrus clouds reflect part of the incoming solar energy, the overriding effect is that they prevent the thermal radiation reflected by the earth from escaping into space, resulting in a climate impact similar to that caused by greenhouse gases. Proponents of this approach believe that if we remove or thin out the cirrus clouds that form in the sky, we could partially offset the greenhouse effect caused by the increased concentration of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere. How could this be done? With aerial vehicles (drones) that inject into the cirrus clouds special solid particles (aerosols) that encourage the formation of larger ice crystals with a shorter life. This would not only make the cirrus clouds disappear more quickly from the sky but they would also have a greater capacity to dissipate heat from the earth into space. The final SRM technology discussed by scientists involves sending fleets of “space sunshades” into orbit that reflect part of the incoming sunlight. Some scientists believe that a two percent reduction in sunlight would be enough to offset the warming caused by the doubling of CO2 concentrations compared to pre-industrial levels. The main problem is that putting one or more space mirrors into orbit is a huge technological challenge with prohibitive costs.
The discussion on solar radiation management technologies remains open and we do not yet know if they will ever be used in the future. The high degree of uncertainty over their effectiveness and especially over the negative collateral impacts fuel the mistrust of a large part of the scientific community, the political decision-makers and society in general, who instead consider essential an approach based on prevention (immediately reducing net greenhouse gas emissions, without compensating for them with other futuristic interventions of little known or unknown effects).
THIS WEBSITE (AND THE INFORMATION CONTAINED HEREIN) DOES NOT CONTAIN OR CONSTITUTE AN OFFER OF SECURITIES FOR SALE, OR SOLICITATION OF AN OFFER TO PURCHASE SECURITIES OR IS NOT FOR RELEASE, PUBLICATION OR DISTRIBUTION, DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY, IN OR INTO THE UNITED STATES (INCLUDING ITS TERRITORIES AND POSSESSIONS, ANY STATE OF THE UNITED STATES AND THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA) OR FOR THE ACCOUNT OR BENEFIT OF ANY U.S. PERSON AS THAT TERM IS DEFINED IN THE SECURITIES ACT (A "U.S. PERSON"), AUSTRALIA, CANADA, JAPAN OR SOUTH AFRICA OR ANY OTHER JURISDICTION WHERE SUCH AN OFFER OR SOLICITATION WOULD REQUIRE THE APPROVAL OF LOCAL AUTHORITIES OR OTHERWISE BE UNLAWFUL (THE "OTHER COUNTRIES"). THE SECURITIES REFERRED TO HEREIN HAVE NOT BEEN AND WILL NOT BE REGISTERED UNDER THE U.S. SECURITIES ACT OF 1933, AS AMENDED (THE "SECURITIES ACT"), OR PURSUANT TO THE CORRESPONDING REGULATIONS IN FORCE IN AUSTRALIA, CANADA, JAPAN, SOUTH AFRICA OR THE “OTHER COUNTRIES” AND MAY NOT BE OFFERED OR SOLD IN THE UNITED STATES OR TO A U.S. PERSON UNLESS THE SECURITIES ARE REGISTERED UNDER THE SECURITIES ACT, OR AN EXEMPTION FROM THE REGISTRATION REQUIREMENTS OF THE SECURITIES ACT IS AVAILABLE. NO PUBLIC OFFERING OF SUCH SECURITIES IS INTENDED TO BE MADE IN THE UNITED STATES, AUSTRALIA, CANADA, JAPAN OR IN THE “OTHER COUNTRIES.”
In any Member State of the European Economic Area ("EEA"), the information contained in this website is only directed at and may only be communicated to persons who are "qualified investors" ("Qualified Investors") within the meaning of Article 2(e) of Regulation (EU) 2017/1129 (the "Prospectus Regulation").
The information to which this website gives access is directed only at persons (i) who are persons falling within Article 49(2)(a) to (d) ("high net worth companies, unincorporated associations etc.") of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 (Financial Promotion) Order 2005 (the "Order") or (ii) who have professional experience in matters relating to investments falling within Article 19(5) of the Order or (iii) to whom it may otherwise lawfully be communicated (all such persons together being referred to as "relevant persons"). Any investment or investment activity to which this communication relates is only available to relevant persons and will be engaged in only with relevant persons, or in the EEA, with Qualified Investors. Any person who is not a relevant person, a Qualified Investor or otherwise permitted under applicable law or regulation to access the information, should not act or rely on the information contained herein.
Confirmation of Understanding and Acceptance of Disclaimer
These materials are for informational purposes only and are not directed to, nor are they intended for, access by persons located or resident in the United States, Australia, Canada, Japan or South Africa or any of the Other Countries. I certify that:
I am not resident of, or located in, the United States, Australia, Canada, Japan or South Africa or any of the Other Countries or I am not a U.S. Person; or
If I am a resident of, or located in, the EEA, I am a Qualified Investor within the meaning of Article 2(e) of the Prospectus Regulation; or
If I am a resident of, or located in, the United Kingdom, I am a Qualified Investor and a relevant person.
I have read and understood the disclaimer set out above. I understand that it may affect my rights. I agree to be bound by its terms and I am permitted under applicable law and regulations to proceed to the following parts of this website.
WARNING: the above certification constitutes a "self-certification" pursuant to Decree of the President of the Italian Republic No. 445 of 28 December 2000. False certifications are punishable by law.
You must read the following information before continuing.
The information contained in this segment of the website is not intended for, and must not be accessed or distributed or disseminated to persons resident or physically present in the United Kingdom, Canada, Australia, Japan or any other jurisdiction in which it is unlawful to do so. The information also is not intended for, and must not be accessed or distributed or disseminated to persons resident or physically present in Italy who are not “qualified investors” (investitori qualificati), as defined in Article 2, letter e) of Regulation (EU) 2017/1129 (the “Prospectus Regulation”) pursuant to Article 1, fourth paragraph, letter a) of the Prospectus Regulation as implemented in Italy by Article 35, paragraph 1, letter d) of CONSOB regulation No. 20307 of February 15, 2018.
By clicking the button below labeled “I agree”, you are certifying that (A) if you are in the European Economic Area, you are a “Qualified Investor”; (B) you are not accessing this portion of the website from the United Kingdom, Australia, Canada or Japan; (C) if you are a resident or physically present in Italy, you are a qualified investor as defined under the Prospectus Regulation as implemented in Italy by Article 35, paragraph 1, letter d) of CONSOB regulation No. 20307 of February 15, 2018; and (D) you are not located in a jurisdiction where it is unlawful to access this portion of the website.
You acknowledge that the information and statements contained in the document you are accessing on this website speak only as of the date of such document (or such other date(s) specified therein), and such information and statements may become inaccurate, stale and/or out-of-date thereafter and should not be relied upon for any investment decision.
You acknowledge that the materials on this website that you are accessing are confidential and intended only for you and you agree you will not forward, reproduce, copy, download or publish any of such materials (electronically or otherwise) to any other person if this is not in accordance with the law.
You acknowledge that the access to information and documents contained on this portion of the website may be illegal in certain jurisdictions, and only certain categories of persons may be authorized to access this portion of the website. If you are not authorized to access the information and document contained on this portion of the website or you are not sure that you are permitted to view these materials, you should leave this portion of the website.
You acknowledge that no registration or approval has been obtained and Eni Gas e Luce S.p.A. società benefit and its affiliates assume no responsibility if there is a violation of applicable law and regulation by any person.
By clicking the button below labeled “I agree”, you are confirming that you have read and understood the disclaimer above.
If you cannot so confirm, you must exit this portion of the website
